Boutique Inns

Top Boutique Inns

These exceptional properties represent the best of Nantucket's boutique lodging scene, each offering distinctive character and warm hospitality.

• 1

  Union Street Inn

  7 Union Street, Downtown Nantucket

  Set in an impeccably restored 1770 whaling captain's home, Union Street Inn epitomizes elegant Nantucket hospitality. Just steps from Main Street, this 12-room inn features period antiques, fine linens, and modern amenities including marble bathrooms and individual climate control. Each morning begins with a gourmet breakfast in the sunny dining room or on the garden patio. The innkeepers' attention to detail - from fresh flowers to evening turndown service - creates a refined yet welcoming atmosphere. The central location makes this an ideal base for exploring downtown while retreating to peaceful elegance at day's end.

• 2

  The Cottages at Nantucket Boat Basin

  24 Old South Wharf, Nantucket Harbor

  For those who dream of waking to harbor views and the gentle sound of boats, The Cottages at Nantucket Boat Basin offer an unmatched waterfront experience. These individually designed cottages and studios sit directly on the working waterfront, with private decks overlooking yacht-filled waters. Each unit features full kitchens, living areas, and nautical-inspired decor that celebrates the island's maritime heritage. The property includes complimentary use of Mercedes-Benz vehicles for exploring the island. Watch fishing boats return with the day's catch, kayak from your doorstep, or simply relax on your deck as the sun sets over the harbor.

• 3

  76 Main

  76 Main Street, Downtown Nantucket

  Sophisticated yet approachable, 76 Main brings a fresh, contemporary sensibility to Nantucket's historic lodging scene. This stylish boutique hotel occupies a prime Main Street location, putting shops, restaurants, and galleries at your doorstep. The 19 rooms and suites feature modern design with clean lines, luxurious bedding, and spa-inspired bathrooms. A wine bar and restaurant on-site add to the appeal, while the rooftop deck offers a unique vantage point for people-watching and sunset views. The young, friendly staff creates an energetic atmosphere that appeals to travelers seeking design-forward accommodations without sacrificing Nantucket charm.

• 4

  Martin House Inn

  61 Centre Street, Downtown Nantucket

  Victorian elegance finds its fullest expression at Martin House Inn, a meticulously preserved 1803 mariner's home that transports guests to another era. The 13 rooms are decorated with period antiques, four-poster beds, and fine fabrics that honor the building's heritage while ensuring modern comfort. Common areas include multiple parlors, a wraparound porch perfect for morning coffee, and lovely gardens. A generous continental breakfast featuring homemade baked goods is included, served in the elegant dining room or on the veranda. The inn's peaceful location on a quiet side street offers respite from downtown bustle while remaining an easy walk to everything.

• 5

  Ships Inn

  13 Fair Street, Downtown Nantucket

  History comes alive at Ships Inn, the former home of Captain Obed Starbuck, one of Nantucket's most successful whaling captains and cousin to the inspiration for Starbuck in Moby-Dick. Built in 1831, this Federal-style building now houses 12 beautifully appointed guest rooms, each named after ships from Captain Starbuck's fleet. The inn features an acclaimed restaurant in the basement - itself a destination for island visitors - serving creative American cuisine in an intimate, candlelit setting. A continental breakfast is included, and the innkeepers share fascinating tales of the building's storied past with interested guests.

• 6

  Centerboard Inn

  8 Chester Street, Downtown Nantucket

  Nautical elegance defines Centerboard Inn, where maritime themes are woven throughout with sophistication and restraint. This intimate 7-room inn occupies a beautifully renovated Victorian home, featuring rooms decorated in crisp whites and ocean-inspired blues with elegant appointments. Each accommodation includes luxury bedding, marble bathrooms, and modern amenities. The highlight for many guests is the gourmet breakfast, served in the sunny dining room or delivered to your room upon request. The location on a quiet residential street provides tranquility while remaining just a short walk from downtown. The intimate scale ensures personalized attention from attentive innkeepers.

• 7

  Pineapple Inn

  10 Hussey Street, Downtown Nantucket

  The pineapple, symbol of hospitality, perfectly represents this romantic boutique inn tucked away on a quiet downtown street. Dating to 1838, the Greek Revival building has been lovingly restored to offer 12 guest rooms combining historic character with contemporary luxury. Rooms feature handcrafted four-poster beds, marble bathrooms, and fine linens, while public spaces showcase original architectural details and period furnishings. The lush garden courtyard provides a peaceful retreat for enjoying the included gourmet breakfast or afternoon refreshments. Couples particularly appreciate the inn's romantic ambiance, making it a popular choice for anniversaries and honeymoons.

What Makes Boutique Inns Special

Choosing a boutique inn over a larger hotel or vacation rental offers distinct advantages that enhance the Nantucket experience.

Personalized Service

With typically fewer than 20 rooms, boutique inns provide attentive, personalized service that larger properties cannot match. Innkeepers learn your preferences, remember your name, and go out of their way to ensure memorable stays. Need restaurant recommendations? They'll make the call. Celebrating a special occasion? Expect thoughtful touches in your room. This level of care transforms a hotel stay into a genuinely welcoming experience.

Historic Buildings

Most boutique inns occupy buildings dating to the 18th and 19th centuries, when Nantucket was the whaling capital of the world. Staying in a sea captain's former residence or a Greek Revival mansion connects you to the island's fascinating history in ways no modern hotel can replicate. Original architectural details - wide-plank floors, working fireplaces, hand-hewn beams - provide authentic character you won't find elsewhere.

Unique Room Designs

Unlike chain hotels with identical rooms, boutique inns offer individually designed accommodations, each with its own personality. Historic buildings create rooms of varying sizes, layouts, and features - some with harbor views, others with private gardens, many with working fireplaces or clawfoot tubs. This variety means you can find the perfect room for your preferences and return for a different experience on future visits.

Breakfast Often Included

Most boutique inns include breakfast with your stay, ranging from continental spreads of homemade pastries and fresh fruit to full gourmet breakfasts with hot entrees. Beyond the value proposition, these morning meals provide opportunities to meet fellow travelers and receive personalized recommendations from staff who know the island intimately. Some inns offer breakfast in bed or garden dining for romantic mornings.

Price Range

Boutique inns on Nantucket typically range from $300 to $700 per night, depending on season, room category, and specific property. Peak summer rates (late June through August) command premium prices, with the most desirable rooms at top properties reaching $600-700 nightly. Shoulder seasons (May, September, October) offer better value, often 30-40% below peak rates, with the same quality experience and more availability. Off-season stays can be remarkably affordable, though some inns close during winter months.

When comparing prices, remember that most boutique inns include breakfast and often offer amenities like afternoon refreshments, beach gear, and concierge services that would cost extra elsewhere. The value extends beyond the room rate to encompass a complete hospitality experience.

Choosing the Right Inn

For Romance

Pineapple Inn and Union Street Inn lead for romantic getaways, with intimate settings, luxurious rooms, and gardens perfect for quiet moments together. Both offer special packages for honeymoons and anniversaries.

For Waterfront Location

The Cottages at Nantucket Boat Basin offer the only true waterfront boutique experience, with private decks overlooking the harbor. Perfect for maritime enthusiasts and those who want water views from bed.

For History Buffs

Ships Inn provides the most storied experience, with direct connections to Nantucket's whaling heritage and the Moby-Dick legend. Martin House Inn also offers exceptional period authenticity.

For Modern Sensibilities

76 Main appeals to travelers seeking contemporary design within a historic context, offering the most modern aesthetic while maintaining Nantucket character.

For Best Value

Centerboard Inn and Martin House Inn often offer competitive rates while maintaining high standards, particularly in shoulder seasons. Both include excellent breakfasts that add value to your stay.