Not every meal needs to be a production. These casual spots serve excellent food in relaxed settings - perfect for beach-day refueling, family dinners, or when you just want good food without the fuss.
Something Natural
Best Sandwiches
Legendary sandwiches on homemade bread in a rustic setting. Bike there, grab a sandwich, and eat at picnic tables surrounded by gardens. The quintessential casual Nantucket experience.
Millie's
Best Beach Vibe
Fish tacos, burritos, and frozen drinks in Madaket. Casual to the extreme with excellent food. Perfect before or after watching the sunset at the beach.
The Downyflake
Best Breakfast
Local institution serving hearty breakfasts and famous donuts. Counter seating, no frills, just excellent food. Cash only and proud of it.
Sayle's Seafood
Best Seafood Takeout
Fresh fish market with a takeout window. Lobster rolls, chowder, and fried fish to go. Locals know this is where the value is.
Fog Island Cafe
Best All-Day
Cozy cafe near the harbor serving breakfast and lunch. Excellent coffee, great sandwiches, friendly vibe. Popular with locals year-round.
The Tavern
Best Pub Food
Classic bar with solid pub fare. Burgers, fish and chips, good beer selection. No pretense, just a neighborhood spot.
Cisco Brewers
Best Outdoor Scene
Beer, wine, and spirits with food trucks and live music. The most fun casual hangout on the island. Great for groups and families.
Provisions
Best Gourmet Takeout
Upscale market with excellent prepared foods. Sandwiches, salads, and provisions for beach picnics. Quality without the restaurant wait.
Casual Dining Tips
- No reservations needed at most casual spots
- Many offer takeout for beach picnics
- Lunch crowds are smaller than dinner
- Cash is still preferred at some places
- Early dinner (5-5:30pm) means shorter waits