Nantucket's fine dining scene punches well above its weight. World-class chefs, impeccable ingredients, and settings that match the food - here's where to go when the occasion calls for something special.
The Chanticleer
Most Romantic
Rose-covered cottage in Sconset. French-inspired cuisine in a magical garden setting. The most special occasion restaurant on the island.
Straight Wharf Restaurant
Best Seafood
Waterfront elegance since 1976. Impeccable local seafood prepared with care and creativity. The gold standard for Nantucket dining.
Topper's at The Wauwinet
Most Exclusive
Secluded luxury at the island's most refined hotel. Farm-to-table excellence in an elegant setting. Take the hotel launch for extra romance.
Dune
Most Intimate
Tiny restaurant with big flavor. Creative, seasonal cuisine in a cozy space. Reserve well in advance - there are only a handful of tables.
Company of the Cauldron
Most Unique
Set-menu dining by candlelight. One seating, one menu, no choices - and that's the point. A theatrical culinary experience.
Galley Beach
Best Setting
Toes in the sand, sunset views, exceptional food. The most enviable dinner reservation on the island. Book months ahead.
Oran Mor
Best Bistro Elegance
Intimate bistro with sophisticated cuisine. Local ingredients, thoughtful preparations, excellent wine list.
Fine Dining Tips
- Reserve 2-4 weeks ahead in summer
- Dress is smart casual to elegant
- Mention special occasions when booking
- Expect to spend $150-250+ per person
- Many offer excellent tasting menus