Beyond the crowded beaches and busy Main Street, Nantucket has quiet corners and local favorites waiting to be discovered. Here are the hidden gems that reward those who venture off the beaten path.
Altar Rock
Best Panoramic View
The highest point on the island (101 feet) with 360-degree views of the moors. Most visitors never leave town - you'll likely have this spot to yourself. Accessible via dirt road off Polpis Road.
Greater Light
Quirkiest Museum
A 19th-century pig barn converted into an eccentric artist's home. Strange, wonderful, and utterly unique. Included with NHA Whaling Museum ticket but rarely crowded.
Eel Point
Secret Beach
Remote beach on the island's west end. Requires a walk through conservation land, which keeps the crowds away. Excellent for bird watching and solitude.
Lily Pond Park
Peaceful Stroll
Small park near North Liberty Street with walking paths, pond views, and few visitors. Perfect for a quiet morning walk.
Maria Mitchell Aquarium
Overlooked Attraction
Small aquarium featuring local marine life. Less flashy than mainland aquariums but genuinely educational. Kids can handle live creatures in the touch tank.
African Meeting House
Important History
The only public building remaining from Nantucket's 19th-century African American community. Powerful, moving, and rarely on tourist itineraries.
Sanford Farm at Dawn
Early Bird Reward
This popular hiking spot is magical at sunrise when you'll have it almost entirely to yourself. Watch the mist rise off the moors.
Nantucket Atheneum Garden
Secret Oasis
Behind the beautiful library, a peaceful garden offers a quiet escape from Main Street crowds just steps away.
Old North Cemetery
Historic Walk
Weathered headstones tell the stories of whaling captains and their families. A peaceful, fascinating glimpse into the island's past.
Windswept Bog Loop
Fall Favorite
Working cranberry bog that turns brilliant red in October during harvest. Beautiful any time, spectacular in autumn.
Finding Hidden Gems
- Early morning rewards with solitude at popular spots
- Ask locals - most are happy to share their favorites
- Shoulder season reveals spots crowded in summer
- Bike paths lead to quieter areas
- Conservation lands offer trails away from crowds