A Nantucket summer isn't complete without ice cream. The island's most famous line wraps around the block for a reason, but there are other sweet spots worth discovering too.
The Juice Bar
Most Iconic
The line around the block is worth it. Homemade ice cream with creative flavors. Cash only, no substitutions, utterly delicious. A Nantucket rite of passage.
The Handlebar
Best Alternative
Excellent ice cream without the legendary wait. Quality homemade flavors and friendly service. A smart local choice when The Juice Bar line is too long.
Nantucket Bake Shop
Best Variety
Solid ice cream plus cakes, cookies, and baked goods. Great option when different family members want different treats.
Sconset Market
Best in Sconset
Ice cream at the edge of town in charming Siasconset. Grab a cone after a walk through the village or along the bluff.
Something Natural
Best Setting
Less famous for ice cream but the garden setting is lovely. Grab a cone after your sandwich and enjoy the peaceful atmosphere.
Ice Cream Tips
- The Juice Bar line is shortest mid-afternoon
- After-dinner lines at Juice Bar can be 30+ minutes
- Cash only at The Juice Bar
- Most flavors are seasonal - ask what's fresh
- Get a waffle cone - the extra is worth it