Nantucket punches well above its weight for dining. From upscale waterfront restaurants to cozy bistros and fresh seafood shacks, here are our top picks across all categories.
The Chanticleer
Best Fine Dining
In a rose-covered cottage in Sconset, this legendary restaurant offers French-inspired cuisine in one of the most romantic settings on the island. Garden dining in summer is magical. Reservations essential.
Cru
Best Waterfront
Raw bar and grill on Straight Wharf with stunning harbor views. Exceptional oysters, creative cocktails, and the freshest local seafood. Perfect for a special occasion or impressive first night dinner.
Brotherhood of Thieves
Best Casual
An island institution since 1972. Cozy, historic setting with excellent burgers, curly fries, and a welcoming pub atmosphere. No reservations, but worth the wait.
Ventuno
Best Italian
Sophisticated Italian cuisine in a beautiful Federal Street setting. Excellent pasta, impressive wine list, and a late-night scene at the bar. One of the island's most consistent restaurants.
Millie's
Best Casual Seafood
Tex-Mex meets fresh seafood at Madaket's beloved spot. Fish tacos, burritos, and cold drinks in a laid-back setting. Watch the sunset while you eat.
The Proprietors
Best New American
Creative, locally-sourced cuisine in a stylish India Street setting. Seasonal menu showcases the best of what's available. Outstanding cocktail program.
Straight Wharf Restaurant
Best Classic Nantucket
Refined waterfront dining since 1976. Fresh local seafood, beautiful presentations, legendary service. The quintessential Nantucket fine dining experience.
Black-Eyed Susan's
Best Breakfast/Brunch
Worth the wait for creative breakfast dishes and strong coffee. No reservations, cash only, and always a line in summer - but everyone agrees it's worth it.
Dune
Best for Date Night
Stylish, intimate restaurant with an ever-changing menu of creative dishes. Perfect for a romantic evening. Small space, so reservations are crucial.
Something Natural
Best Sandwiches
Legendary sandwiches on homemade bread. The perfect picnic provisions for a beach day. Get there early - they sell out.
Dining Tips
- Book popular restaurants 2-4 weeks ahead in summer
- Many places close or reduce hours off-season
- Ask about local catch of the day
- Dress is generally smart casual
- Cash only at some casual spots (Brotherhood, Black-Eyed Susan's)