You're on an island 30 miles out to sea - the seafood better be good. It is. From raw bars to lobster rolls to elegant preparations of local catch, here's where to find the best.
Cru
Best Raw Bar
Exceptional oyster selection, perfect preparations, harbor views. The raw bar here is as good as it gets. Also excellent for cooked seafood and cocktails.
Straight Wharf Restaurant
Best Fine Dining Seafood
Elegant preparations of the freshest local fish. Their relationships with local fishermen mean today's catch is on tonight's menu. A Nantucket classic since 1976.
The Lobster Trap
Best Lobster Roll
Classic New England lobster rolls done right. Generous portions of fresh lobster on buttered rolls. Casual atmosphere, reasonable (for Nantucket) prices.
Sayle's Seafood
Best Takeout
Fresh fish market with a takeout window. Get a lobster roll, fish sandwich, or clam chowder to take to the beach. Local's favorite for quality and value.
Millie's
Best Fish Tacos
Fresh local fish in creative taco preparations. Casual Madaket spot with sunset views. The fish tacos are legendary.
Brant Point Grill
Best Waterfront
At the White Elephant hotel, offering harbor views and elegant seafood preparations. Great for a special occasion lunch or dinner.
The SeaGrille
Best Variety
Extensive seafood menu with something for everyone. From raw bar to grilled fish to classic preparations. Family-friendly.
Oran Mor
Best Bistro Seafood
Intimate bistro with outstanding seafood preparations. Creative dishes showcasing local catches. Excellent wine list.
Seafood Tips
- Ask about local catch of the day - it's always the freshest
- Nantucket bay scallops (Oct-March) are legendary
- Oyster varieties change seasonally
- Lobster is fresh all summer but best in fall
- Many restaurants have raw bar specials during happy hour