Casual Dining

Top Casual Dining Spots

These are the island favorites where locals and visitors alike come for great food in a relaxed setting. No reservations required - just show up hungry.

• 1

  Provisions

  Straight Wharf, Downtown

  The go-to spot for gourmet sandwiches and picnic supplies. Provisions has been crafting artisan sandwiches, salads, and prepared foods for decades. Perfect for beach picnics or a quick lunch in town. Their specialty sandwiches feature quality meats, fresh-baked bread, and creative combinations. Don't miss their selection of local cheeses and charcuterie.

• 2

  Something Natural

  Cliff Road

  A Nantucket institution serving legendary sandwiches since 1970. Built on thick slices of their famous homemade bread - Portuguese, oatmeal, or herb varieties - these generous sandwiches are a rite of passage for island visitors. The rustic outdoor seating area with picnic tables under the trees creates a quintessential Nantucket experience. Cash only, and worth the slight trek from downtown.

• 3

  B-ACK Yard BBQ

  Fairgrounds Road

  Nantucket's answer to low-and-slow barbecue, complete with a lively beer garden atmosphere. Smoked brisket, pulled pork, ribs, and all the classic sides are served up in a casual outdoor setting with picnic tables and lawn games. The beer garden features local craft brews and a fun, festive vibe that's perfect for groups. Live music on select evenings adds to the party atmosphere.

• 4

  The Juice Bar

  Broad Street, Downtown

  Famous for homemade ice cream, but The Juice Bar is also a solid choice for quick, casual eats. Beyond their legendary ice cream (expect lines in summer - it's worth it), they serve breakfast items, sandwiches, and light fare. The downtown location makes it perfect for a break while shopping or strolling through town. Their waffle cones are made fresh daily.

• 5

  Walter's

  Upper Main Street

  A beloved neighborhood pub serving comfort food and craft beers in a welcoming atmosphere. The menu features elevated pub classics - think gourmet burgers, fish and chips, and hearty salads - alongside an impressive beer selection. The vibe is casual and friendly, making it popular with locals year-round. Great spot to catch a game or enjoy a relaxed dinner.

• 6

  Fog Island Cafe

  South Water Street

  A breakfast and lunch institution that's been feeding Nantucket for over two decades. Known for creative breakfast dishes, excellent coffee, and a cozy atmosphere that locals love. Their pancakes, omelets, and breakfast sandwiches are island favorites. Lunch features fresh salads, sandwiches, and daily specials. Arrive early on weekends to avoid the wait - it's that popular.

• 7

  Sayle's Seafood

  Washington Street Extension

  A working fish market that also serves some of the island's freshest prepared seafood. Order lobster rolls, fried clams, fish sandwiches, and chowder at the counter, then grab a seat at the outdoor picnic tables. It's no-frills dining with seafood that couldn't be fresher - much of it comes right off the boats docked nearby. A true local experience away from the tourist crowds.

Best for Families

Traveling with kids? These restaurants welcome families with kid-friendly menus, relaxed atmospheres, and understanding staff who won't flinch at the occasional spill.

• B-ACK Yard BBQ: The outdoor beer garden setting means kids can move around, and the finger-food-friendly menu (ribs, wings, mac and cheese) is a hit with all ages. Lawn games keep everyone entertained.
• The Juice Bar: What kid doesn't love ice cream? The quick service and casual atmosphere make this an easy stop with little ones.
• Fog Island Cafe: Pancakes, french toast, and friendly service make breakfast here a family favorite. The relaxed vibe means no one minds a bit of chaos.
• Something Natural: The outdoor picnic table seating means kids can roam a bit, and the sandwiches can be customized for picky eaters. The property has a charming, rustic feel kids enjoy exploring.
• Sayle's Seafood: Outdoor seating, casual ordering, and simple fried seafood options make this a stress-free choice for families who want fresh fish without the fine dining formality.

Outdoor Dining Options

One of the joys of casual dining on Nantucket is eating al fresco. These spots offer memorable outdoor settings where you can enjoy the island breeze with your meal.

• Something Natural: Their shaded picnic area under mature trees is one of the island's most charming outdoor dining spots. Pure Nantucket atmosphere.
• B-ACK Yard BBQ: The beer garden features expansive outdoor seating with picnic tables, string lights, and a fun, festive atmosphere.
• Sayle's Seafood: Waterside picnic tables offer views of the working harbor - watch fishing boats while you enjoy your lobster roll.
• Provisions: While primarily takeout, they have limited outdoor seating, or grab your picnic supplies and head to a nearby wharf or bench.
• The Juice Bar: Outdoor benches and a prime downtown location make people-watching part of the experience.

Budget-Friendly Picks

Eating on Nantucket doesn't have to break the bank. These casual spots offer great value without sacrificing quality.

• Provisions: Sandwiches and prepared foods offer filling meals at reasonable prices, especially compared to sit-down restaurants.
• Something Natural: Generous sandwich portions at fair prices - you might even have enough for two meals.
• Sayle's Seafood: Fresh-off-the-boat seafood at fish market prices rather than restaurant markups. Their fish sandwiches and fried clams offer great value.
• Fog Island Cafe: Breakfast and lunch prices are more accessible than dinner-focused restaurants, with portions that satisfy.
• The Juice Bar: Light meals and snacks won't strain the vacation budget, though the ice cream is an essential indulgence.

Tip: Consider splitting a couple of sandwiches or entrees among the group - portions at many casual spots are generous.